Date of Award
2026
Document Type
Dissertation
Degree Name
Doctor of Education (EdD)
Department
Education
First Advisor
Dr. Julie Milner, EdD., Esq.
Second Advisor
Dr. Chad Walerstein, EdD.
Third Advisor
Dr. Paula Lester, PhD.
Abstract
This study examines the fidelity, urgency, and challenges of implementing the middle school concept in non-traditional middle school settings. The study uses the Association of Middle Level Education’s This We Believe (2021) framework which recommends eighteen essential characteristics that affirm and support effective middle schools across three categories. Using a convergent-parallel mixed methods approach, incorporating a quantitative survey, data was collected from seventh and eighth grade middle level teachers across five schools within one, suburban Long Island district. This qualitatively driven mixed-methods study used framework-coded thematic analysis of teacher interviews, supported by descriptive survey data, to examine perceived fidelity to AMLE’s This We Believe (Bishop & Harrison, 2021) in one non-traditional grades 7–12 district. In addition, optional qualitative semi-structured interviews were conducted with fifteen middle-level interdisciplinary team teachers across the same district to assess their perceptions of middle level practice and its fidelity to recommended middle level best practices. The study captures teacher perceptions of the middle school concept and how their approaches align or deviate from it, using a Likert-type survey and semi-structured interviews to evaluate teacher knowledge of, individual operationalization of, and school-based adherence to the middle school concept. Based on teacher perceptions and feedback, the study uses data ascertained to suggest recommendations for additional support in applying AMLE’s This We Believe framework and best middle school practice to target young adolescents and better serve their academic and developmental needs in non-traditional middle school settings. Participants were accessed using purposive sampling to ensure the study’s participants captured the perceptions of middle level teachers working in non-traditional middle school settings.
Recommended Citation
DiScala, Bryan J,, "Teacher Perceptions of Middle School Concept Fidelity in a Non-Traditional 7–12 Setting: A Mixed-Methods Study of One Suburban District" (2026). Selected Full Text Dissertations, 2011-. 178.
https://digitalcommons.liu.edu/post_fultext_dis/178